| 2025 | Emily Lamparter | Lacrosse | Weaver-James-Corrigan-Swofford |
| 2025 | Lucas Mahlstedt | Baseball | Weaver-James-Corrigan-Swofford |
| 2025 | Andrew Swanson | Men's Golf | ACC Excellence Award |
| 2025 | Rebecca Wells | Gymnastics | ACC Excellence Award |
| 2024 | Will Putnam | Football | Weaver-James-Corrigan-Swofford |
| 2024 | Megan Bornkamp | Women's Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan-Swofford |
| 2024 | Ousmane Sylla | Men's Soccer | ACC Excellence Award |
| 2024 | Halle Mackiewicz | Women's Soccer | ACC Excellence Award |
| 2023 | K.J. Henry | Football | ACC Excellence Award |
| 2023 | Mckenna Slavik | Volleyball | Weaver-James-Corrigan-Swofford |
| 2023 | Hal Hershfelt | Women's Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan-Swofford |
| 2022 | Sydney Dawson | Women's Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan-Swofford |
| 2022 | George Marks | Men's Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan-Swofford |
| 2022 | Cammy Pereira | Softball | Weaver-James-Corrigan-Swofford |
| 2021 | Marissa Giumbarda | Softball | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2021 | Courtney Jones | Women's Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2021 | Grace Mattimore | Softball | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2021 | William Nottingham | Men's Golf | Weaver-James-Corrigan# |
| 2020 | Ana Paula Valdes | Women's Golf | Weaver-James-Corrigan# |
| 2019 | Christian Wilkins | Football | Weaver-James-Corrigan# |
| 2019 | Miranda Weslake | Women's Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2019 | Alice Hewson | Women's Golf | Weaver-James-Corrigan & Thacker |
| 2018 | Oliver Shannon | Men's Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan# |
| 2018 | Grace Barnett | Women's Cross Country/Track | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2018 | Marisa Messana | Women's Golf | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2018 | Daniela Ruiz Alvarez | Women's Tennis | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2017 | Deshaun Watson | Football | Weaver-James-Corrigan# |
| 2017 | Abby Jones | Women's Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2017 | Gabby Byorth | Women's Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2017 | Emily Byorth | Women's Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2016 | Anna Skochdopole | Rowing | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2016 | Jordan Roper | Men's Basketball | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2016 | Tristen Dewar | Women's Tennis | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2015 | Hunter Harrington | Men's Tennis | Weaver-James-Corrigan# |
| 2015 | Katelyn Reeve | Women's Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2015 | Romy Koelzer | Women's Tennis | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2015 | Ara Amirkhanian | Men's Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2014 | Thomas McNamara | Men's Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan & Thacker |
| 2014 | Chandler Catanzaro | Football | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2014 | Emily Howard | Women's Swimming & Diving | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2014 | Alex Stockinger | Men's Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan# |
| 2013 | Rashard Hall | Football | Jim and Pat Thacker |
| 2013 | Natalie Patzin | Volleyball | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2013 | Alexa Rand | Volleyball | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2012 | Becca Brown | Rowing | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2012 | Alyssa Kulik | Women’s Cross Country | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2012 | Tanner Smith | Men’s Basketball | Weaver-James-Corrigan# |
| 2012 | Dawson Zimmerman | Football | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2011 | Stephanie Buffo | Women’s Cross Country/Track & Field | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2011 | Elizabeth Savage | Women’s Swimming & Diving | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2011 | Michael Wade | Football | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2011 | Patricia Mamona | Women’s Track & Field | Weaver-James-Corrigan# |
| 2010 | Gregory Eckhardt | Men’s Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2010 | Ben Martin | Golf | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2010 | Michelle Nance | Rowing | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2010 | Katrina Obas | Women’s Swimming & Diving | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2009 | Megan Bendik | Rowing | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2009 | Jimmy Maners | Football | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2009 | Rachel Regone | Women’s Swimming & Diving | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2008 | Cliff Hammonds | Men’s Basketball | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2008 | Elizabeth Jobe | Women’s Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2008 | Meghan Steiner | Volleyball | Jim and Pat Thacker |
| 2007 | Sarah Cefalu | Women’s Swimming & Diving | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2007 | Brittany Gamble | Rowing | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2007 | Thomas Hunter | Football | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2007 | Britten Myer | Women’s Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2006 | Ashlee Brown | Rowing | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2006 | Nichole Carlton | Women’s Swimming & Diving | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2006 | Bradley Gibson | Men’s Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2006 | Paige Ledford | Women’s Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2006 | Brooke Queenan | Women’s Basketball | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2005 | Mary Nell Green | Rowing | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2005 | Shelly Klaus | Women’s Swimming & Diving | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2005 | Gisele Oliveira | Women’s Track & Field | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2004 | Tony Elliott | Football | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2004 | Allison Mitchell | Women’s Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2004 | Kanetra Queen | Women’s Basketball | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2003 | Jenna Burtch | Women’s Swimming & Diving | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2003 | Jackie Robinson | Football | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2002 | Chad Carson | Football | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2002 | Katie Carson | Women’s Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2001 | Lauren Henne | Rowing | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2000 | Alison Coday | Volleyball | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 2000 | Beth Keller | Women’s Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 1999 | Jennifer Mihalik | Women’s Swimming & Diving | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 1999 | Tom Wideman | Men’s Basketball | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 1999 | Will York | Men’s Swimming & Diving | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 1998 | Angela Brames | Women’s Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 1997 | Craig Wenning | Men’s Soccer | Weaver-James-Corrigan |
| 1996 | Anthony McCrorey | Football | Weaver-James |
| 1995 | Ronald Glenn Jr. | Football | Weaver-James |
| 1995 | Jodie Phillips | Women’s Track & Field | Weaver-James |
| 1994 | Jaroslaw Zawislan | Men’s Soccer | Weaver-James |
| 1993 | Anthony Knight | Men’s Track & Field | Jim Weaver |
| 1992 | Elizabeth Dolan | Women’s Swimming & Diving | Marie James |
| 1992 | Bruce Batton | Football | Bob James |
| 1991 | Dov Kremer | Men’s Track & Field | Jim Weaver |
| 1991 | Kelly Ann Wong | Women’s Swimming & Diving | Marie James |
| 1989 | Henrik Skov | Men’s Track & Field | Jim Weaver |
| 1987 | Denise Murphy | Volleyball | Marie James |
| 1980 | Bobby Conrad | Men’s Basketball | Jim Weaver |
| 1979 | Steve Fuller | Football | Jim Weaver |
| 1973 | Ben Anderson | Football | Jim Weaver |
| # – honorary Award Winner | | | |
